175 Comments

Interesting that we know more about this guy then we know about the Butler, PA Trump shooter.

Expand full comment

I was thinking the exact same thing! It’s very odd. For someone supposedly so intelligent he made a lot of stupid mistakes. It does seem that he was mentally and possibly physically ill. He had spinal X-rays and books on chronic pain so many things are possible here. In his manifesto apparently were some things about the “healthcare system “( sick care system as some call it), giving a pill for this and then when a person is depressed over their situation, giving another pill for that. I’m completely paraphrasing what I read in another article.

We sure have learned a lot about him in this short amount of time vs Thomas Crooks, a person about who we still know very little. Maybe when Trump gets in office he can put someone in charge of that investigation.

Expand full comment

The contrast between what we now know about Mangione (after five days) and what we now know about Crooks(after around five months) is absolutely mind boggling. What you are seeing here is the Deep State in action.

Expand full comment

Progressivism is the disease. That's pretty much what Alex is saying without saying it.

Expand full comment

Unreal, isn't it?

We wouldn't know anything about the Butler assassin if it wasn't for pesky cellphone videos.

The case would've been "solved" the next day.

Expand full comment

We know both lived un Hawaii for a while. Are they connected, as patsies?

Expand full comment

He and Thompson both graduated University of Iowa.

Expand full comment

No the shooter went to Penn.

Expand full comment

You're right I misread that, my bad.

Expand full comment

Stop asking questions and trying to connect dots.

Expand full comment

Amen. Shut up and lie down.

Expand full comment

lol- yep…

Expand full comment

My thoughts exactly! It's almost like the Trump shooter didn't even exist!

Expand full comment

There's nothing mysterious here. If you don't post all your personal thoughts and info on social media, then no one will know your innermost thoughts and actions. Perhaps there's lesson for all of us?

Expand full comment

I’m seeing a lot of skepticism at this “preponderance of evidence” they found on him. Awfully convenient for the note, murder weapon, and clothing to all be retrieved when they found him, far away from the scene of the crime. Nothing about that feels fishy?

Expand full comment

not as fishy as the mcdonald's worker recognizing him from all the conflicting public photos, calling the police, and then the police taking it seriously enough to somehow get there before he finished his big mac.

Expand full comment

Seriously?? When I saw the full face photo posted online on Friday, I predicted he would be in custody within 24 hours. I was wrong on the timeline, but it was only a matter of time before someone spotted him.

Expand full comment

Being privileged and a good student does not equate to street smarts.

Expand full comment

Unless it was the intent to be caught

Expand full comment

Bingo

Expand full comment

It feels more like a typical elitist attitude. He wasn’t worried about getting caught with evidence because he is quite sure that he is smarter than anybody else, especially the losers in law enforcement. He was certain he had easily pulled off the crime of the decade.

Expand full comment

There's a great line in the movie "Body Heat" with William Hurt and Kathleen Turner. An arsonist, played by Mickey Rourke, tells Hurt's character: "Anytime you try a decent crime, there's 50 ways you can fuck up. If you think of 25 of them you're a genius. And you ain't no genius." Mangione wasn't a genius either.

Expand full comment

Absolutely! He was smart, but also young - did not yet realize what he didn't know. Going into Starbucks before the shooting showed how little he knew about "getting away with it."

Expand full comment

Maybe the valedictorian just wasn't all that smart after all.

Expand full comment

100% I have been to that Altoona McDonald’s maybe 15 times. No shot an employee there knew it was him. This is rural Pa. IQ is below 80

Expand full comment

Has anyone else noticed that the photos of the killer from the hostel and/or taxi (which I have no doubt actually show the killer) look markedly different from the photos of Mangione's face (killer's eyebrows look much further apart than Mangione's, for example)?

Expand full comment
1dEdited

I find it interesting that a guy who was able to be on the run for days was caught with the actual gun, silencer and fake ID that he used to commit the crime. Its seems just too clean

Expand full comment

don't forget about the manifesto!

i don't think he should have done it, but if he was going to walk around with all that kit forever - he might as well have worn a gopro & livestreamed it all

Expand full comment

Maybe it's just my skeptical nature, but all just seems a bit too perfect As if it is meant to be all be nicely wrapped up and the media will move on and no one will ask any more questions.

Expand full comment

His schooling obviously radicalized him like it has most of these similar types of people. That is exactly why I am hesitant to send my kids off to a non-Christian High School, let alone just about any college other than Hillsdale. I'm Catholic and there isn't one Catholic University worth a damn these days. I want the Catholic University I graduated from to fail.

Expand full comment

Or, pray that it would be redeemed by some great leadership.

Expand full comment

You might look into Thomas Aquinas College, which has a west coast and an east coast campus. It’s a highly rated liberal arts college which uses the Great Books as the core of its curriculum.

I have six nephews and a niece who are graduates; all are doing very well professionally especially my 49 year old nephew who retired this past year. He’s sending his children to TAC.

Another good school is Franciscan University in Steubenville, Ohio.

Christendom College in Front Royal, VA likewise produces wonderful graduates.

Expand full comment

Hillsdale College also very solid.

Expand full comment

I'll give 10:1 odds that high potency pot is a vital ingredient to this tragic murder fueled by such paranoid delusion.

https://thebeagledotcom.wordpress.com/2024/12/08/last-weeks-assassination-may-have-mortally-wound-your-healthcare/

Expand full comment

That or medications for anxiety as so commonly found correlated-found with mass shootings

Expand full comment

Patients with CIP (Cannabis Induced Psychosis) are frequently on benzos for the voices etc. And most primary care docs are going to use SSRIs like Prozac on such patients--even though they don't help for psychosis and may make things worse. Doesn't sound like this guy had CIP. But even as common as that has become, there is a much larger population of people who have more subtle symptoms like paranoia or delusional thinking. THC doesn't make someone a Jihadist, insurrectionist or Antifa. But it makes people more susceptible to such radicalization. You can't explain the last decade's craziness absent something in the air--which of course is right in front of our noses.

Expand full comment

Makes one wonder given this failed back surgery (FBS) mention, just when Mangione began taking a various cocktail of meds for coping reasons. What was he ON exactly, and just when did he plan this execution of CEO. Was the planning began pre meds or post medication dosing. Hmmmm

Expand full comment

Should be federal law that arrested and dead shooter's toxicology reports be released to the public.

Expand full comment

Such common sense too, but those special interests behind the scene would not approve of such transparency would they.

Expand full comment

Authorities are afraid of violating medical privacy laws. So it would take another federal law to override.

Expand full comment

Exactly my thoughts!!! Drug induced psychosis, etc…

Expand full comment

Good to hear an MD say this because it was one of the first things I suspected.

Expand full comment

More likely the clot shots.

Expand full comment

The rise in "inexplicable" shootings started about a decade before mRNA vaccines coinciding with the advent of another "medicine".

Expand full comment

Of course there's been inexplicable violence before the mRNA "vaccines." Throughout history, actually. That doesn't rule them out as a contributing factor today. I've read many reports of a connection between them and psychotic behavior.

Expand full comment

As many things these shots are responsible for, and there are a lot, I’m doubtful this is one of them…

Expand full comment

As a pediatric nurse practitioner the first question that springs in to my mind upon hearing of a mass shooting is: "What medications was the shooter on?" I have thought this since Columbine.

There are several categories of meds that have "behavioral activation" as a side effect. That is, previously calm people become physically aggressive or even violent after starting on a psychotropic drug. I have seen this particularly with stimulants used for ADHD (e.g., Ritalin).

Heck, even steroids can produce aggression.

Other categories of drugs can induce suicidality (SSRIs) & I was taught during my psych rotation in nursing school at Bellevue that someone who is suicidal is also potentially homicidal. And then there's the worst: second-generation atypical anti-psychotics (e.g., Seroquel, Risperdal) which are prescribed for anything & everything & very often make the patient worse. Here in NYC since the legalization of marijuana we are inundated with raving vagrants everywhere one goes.

Then again, in the case at hand, the shooter is at the tail end of the age range for emerging

schizophrenia. So, who knows? I agree with a later comment by Dr. Poling: Publish the toxicology reports!

Ilene Heller, RN, MS, CPNP

Expand full comment

Why are they on medications? Answer: mental health symptoms. Yes, some "first line" medications can make someone with undiagnosed psychosis worse. But the more common pattern in these "inexplicable crimes" is marijuana leading to mental health symptoms leading to medications which may or may not work.

Expand full comment

Yes, it will be interesting to learn--providing we do--what drugs/even medications, he may have been regularly using. Many people dealing with chronic pain issues use or increase their use of cannibis.

Expand full comment

Someone needs to explain to me how this punk, acting alone, managed to perfectly intersect with his target.

Expand full comment

I want to know what happened in the last roughly 2 hours prior to him deciding to walk out of that hotel without his 24/7 security detail..... and then the shooter just happened to be there. Something is off. I am glad other people are thinking it as well. I feel like I am wearing 3 tin foil hats sometimes.

Expand full comment

So, you basically just proved my point, minus the "2 hours prior to him deciding to walk out of that hotel without his 24/7 security detail". WHY did he not have security that day, like every major CEO does? Especially THAT DAY. This security expert was even the head of Thompson's private security in the past. He is even saying this is "completely unusual". So, thank you for backing me up, Beth.

Expand full comment

I didn't back you up because what you wrote isn't factual. You wrote "... without his 24/7 security detail." Again, what 24/7 security detail? He never had it. From NBC News: "Thompson did not have a dedicated security detail, in contrast to some other executives in the health-insurance sector." https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/business/money-report/executives-seek-more-protection-after-unitedhealthcare-ceo-thompson-killing-kroll-says/3575663/?os=roku%2F&ref=app

Expand full comment

Due to your astute calling me out, I did more research. If you read other articles (https://nypost.com/2024/12/05/us-news/expert-wonders-why-ceo-brian-thompson-had-no-security-in-nyc/), (https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/05/business/corporate-security-unitedhealthcare-ceo-shooting/index.html), there are conflicting reports. The same guy in the Fox News article says he has personally been on Thompson's private security detail in the past. The CNN article clearly states in the first paragraph that he did have a security detail on this NYC trip, and that article is from today (as opposed to the articles you posted which were from the 5th and the 6th). So, I'm going to ask again, why were they not with him at that time? Did he refuse? Was it pulled? I'm not sure it is completely clear at this point. What I do know is that security experts are asking the same questions that I am.... why didn't he have security at that time? They are stunned that he didn't, especially that day and with the threats he had been receiving. There are quotes saying that even if his security was with him, it is unclear if they would have been able to prevent his assassination. Of course, we will never know, because they were not there.

Thank you for your contribution to the discussion.

Expand full comment

I wish this issue of a security detail would be clarified. Just adds to my questions.

Expand full comment

The party of the elites claims to be the party of the common person while doing everything to destroy the ability of that person to succeed by shutting down opportunity based on merit instead of superficial irrelevant characteristics.

Expand full comment

John Leake has also been writing some detailed and interesting things on Substack about this killing. He also questions why Mangione had all those incriminating items on his person, days later.

Either he did it and wanted to be caught, or…someone else did it and he’s a decoy, to get the police off the track of the actual killer. Leake puts the two security photos next to each other, and one can see that the eyebrows seem quite different. Bad camera? Or different man?

Expand full comment

He was arrogant. Like most leftist "progressives."

Expand full comment

The goal seems to be for them to attempt to divide people by race, gender, success etc in order to rule them.

Expand full comment

During the 1st 72 hours of this planned pre meditated killing my 1st thoughts were like many with it being some health insurance personal grievance which is still may be a motive, but after seeing Mangione lash out verbally as he was being taken into the jail last eve just struck me as a person who wanted to be caught, and society as a whole to NOTICE him. He was not concerned with being caught....surprised maybe where it occurred, but his EGO in listening to him was very revealing...at least for me. The time taken to write a manifesto bolsters this for me, but then again maybe it was written by another. Time will tell...maybe!

Expand full comment

His anger appeared to be real and from the heart. A true believer. I recall Lee Harvey did not scream out in anger, but claimed he was being set up as a patsy. Not this guy.

Expand full comment

Yes...was striking in that regard wasn't IT

Expand full comment

He yelled out: “It’s completely out of touch and an insult to the intelligence of the American people and their lived experience!” Appears to me to be the rant of a psychopath.

Expand full comment

Exactly! So listening a few mins ago to a former roommate of Mangione say he never saw this side of Luigi. Did this psychopathic transition occur post failed back fusion taking a concoction of medication OR was it always there?

Expand full comment

Alex you are DEAD on about back surgery realities!

Expand full comment

Alex knows-

Expand full comment

I can’t believe they’d do a fusion on a 26 yo!

Expand full comment

LOL, seriously? These are the same people who will cut the breasts off a 12-year old.

Expand full comment

Can't say I "like" your comment, but you are spot on with your observation.

Expand full comment

My thought too, but not seeing the MRI or other reports perhaps it was pretty severe injury. Rare regardless at that age for sure

Expand full comment

There's something about this scenario (the actual crime, the perp's getaway & temporary escape,

the capture in the MacDonald's) that stinks to high heaven. I've thought from the beginning that he was hired to do it. He seems just the type that an agency like the CIA would recruit to do its dirty work (the CIA does recruit at the Ivies). Also, to me, he doesn't really look like the person in the surveillance photos from the hostel. Anybody else skeptical?

Expand full comment

This whole situation is nothing if not one massive SKEPTICAL :) Just what will BE the final "official" finding and when will that be told lol

Expand full comment

I predict he shoots himself in the head a couple of times.

Expand full comment

No, I disagree. I think someone else will shoot him (think: Lee Harvey Oswald)

to keep him from talking about who hired him. Before the government covid response & the 2020 election results I stayed away from conspiracy theories.

I'm still not all in on them, but now I consider them.

Expand full comment

Just NO WAY a person coming thru the plandemic CON can ever view otherwise. Its a DIFF world now and America. Staying AWAKE has never been more important and those you "choose" to trust

Expand full comment

Or someone DOES for what reason is the question

Expand full comment

I still want answers as to why he was going to testify to the DOJ. Would it be a coincidence if it was about illegal insider trading? Dig deeper Alex. Too many layups on the “evidence “ to try and make it like he is a UnaBomber wanna be. Tea leaves my man.

Expand full comment

Also, is there a connection to the Change HealthCare cyber security breach months ago....?

Expand full comment

He being Thompson.

Expand full comment

I vaguely remember reading that UHC was being investigated as part of an anti-trust suit.

Expand full comment

I thought it was for insider trading?

Expand full comment

You may be right!

Expand full comment

Look into his family ties to Pelosi. They are deep.

The perps family has ties to Pelosi.

In addition, one day before UHC announced the massive data breach, Pelosi’s husband bought stock (I think calls) on Palo Alto Networks.

And who did UHC announce that they had hired to help them unwind the breach. Indeed. Palo Alto Networks

And the victim was being investigated by DOJ. And maybe was set to testify b4 a Congressional Committee about the breach.

Maybe he knew why Pelosi knew ahead of time.

There is something that smells about the entire thing. Nobody plans to the extent the perp planned, and then allows himself to get caught like that. They still haven’t solved the OKC Bombing. Waco. Ruby Ridge. Nashville. Boston Bombing.

And we should believe they got this in 5 days?

Something smells.

Expand full comment

where are you seeing the "family" links to Pelosi?

Expand full comment

I believe I read somewhere that the alleged killer’s Baltimore family were acquainted with Pelosi’s Baltimore family.

Expand full comment

I would appreciate a link to that article. I too heard that those being investigated for insider trading included a long list of prominent people, Nancy Pelosi included. My son has used the App created to follow her husband’s investment strategies. If that whole thing isn’t suspicious, I don’t know what is…

Expand full comment

Simple fact, an insurance company has to pay out less than it takes in as revenue. Unlike Social Security. If they pay out too much, they go broke. Medical expenses are based on getting enough to survive. For example, from 2019-2021 my Medicare approved expenses were in excess of $600,000. They paid nothing like that. Hospitals were lucky if they got 15% of the bill, so they have to make it up elsewhere. The system is fu__'ed but how can it be fixed. I'm too old to try.

Expand full comment

Medical providers know in advance they won't get their full invoice paid by medicare. I started to say it's a big game, but it's not even that. It's more like kabuki theater. Both sides are in on it. They do it for the audience.

Expand full comment

Right you are. All these providers settle for what Medicare pays happily. They know they will get their money. Our local hospital charges off several millions each year for Medicare, Medicaid and indigent care.

Expand full comment

there lies the rub..."enough to survive" From all accounts, and by how most of those insurance companies buildings look they are surviving just FINE!

Expand full comment

Yes it’s a business and as such their primary goal is to make money. The same is true for hospitals. Very important to remember. Oftentimes the first default step is to deny the claim for a nitpicky reason. Have to be a very squeaky wheel and even then it’s no guarantee. Write everything down. Call weekly at least and ask for a call log number and the name of the person with whom you spoke. Many other tips I won’t go into here, but you get the point. It’s very time consuming and the average patient doesn’t speak the language. They count on this, and also that you’re busy and will just go away.

Expand full comment

The whole of social welfare rationalizes itself the way Mangione rationalized his shooting - self-determined, subjective moral declarations by self-appointed gods being imposed on all of society.

This mindset is widespread and deeply entrenched, and it is antithetical to the Rule of Law, which requires formal, universal rules and processes for dealing with violations.

Expand full comment

Mangione declared himself to be the standard by which he judged the execution to be justified. Yes - antithetical to the Rule of Law.

Expand full comment